AdRelevance Intelligence
 

future industry updates | archived reports

Dot Coms in the Driver's Seat

An analysis of the Top 200 Online Advertisers comparing dot coms and traditional companies.

  Download PDF (122k) 

By Marc Ryan 
 
 

It seems that every day there's a new company looking to do business on the Internet. With low overhead and minimal start-up costs, some have hailed the Internet as an entrepreneur's dream. It's no surprise that as the number of Internet start-ups continues to grow and open shop, they turn to the Internet to get their message out to the public. Over the past year alone, the average number of online advertisers has grown steadily from 1,000 per week in July of 1999 to over 4,000 in June of 2000.

To help understand this growth, many analysts look to the amount of online advertising that comes from traditional offline brands. Considering that Internet advertising expenditures in 1999 were a mere five percent of total ad expenditures for all media, there's a lot of room for the industry to grow. Most analysts are banking on traditional companies warming up to the benefits of the Internet and devoting more of their ad budgets to their online campaigns.

While traditional companies are paying more attention to online advertising, an analysis of the Top 200 advertisers in Q2 2000 reveals that dot coms1 advertising online account for both the largest number of companies and the biggest share of impressions. In fact, dot com advertisers outnumber traditional advertisers two to one.

 
 
Analysis of the Top 200 Online Advertiser by Type
2nd Quarter 2000
 
 

As the number of dot coms continues to increase, so do their number of ad impressions. The past year has seen the percentage of dot coms in the Top 200 advertiser rankings increase from 54 percent of the companies in July 1999 to 68 percent in June 2000. Not only is the number of companies increasing, but these companies are also committing a greater percentage of the impressions scheduled by the Top 200 Online Advertisers. In July of 1999, 108 dot coms in the Top 200 rankings committed 64 percent of the Top 200's impressions, while in June 2000, 138 dot coms committed 75 percent of the impressions.

 
 
 
Dot Com Share of Companies and Impressions
Top 200 Advertisers
 
Share of Impressions by Industry
2nd Quarter 2000

Industry Share of all Impressions Share of Top 200 Online Advertisers Difference
Web Media 37.1% 42.5% 5.4%
Financial Services 15.3% 18.7% 3.4%
Software 2.9% 4.1% 1.2%
Hardware & Electronics 1.9% 1.3% -0.6%
Travel 3.1% 2.3% -0.8%
Automotive 1.3% 0.4% -0.9%
Entertainment 2.2% 1.2% -1.0%
Telecommunications 4.0% 2.8% -1.2%
Retail 22.7% 21.3% -1.4%
Business to Business 6.5% 5.0% -1.5%
Consumer Goods 2.7% 0.3% -2.4%
 


The clear majority of the Top 200 Online Advertisers are dot com companies. Web Media accounts for the largest industry share of online advertising impressions. This share increases when looking solely at the Top 200 Online Advertiser rankings.
 
 
 

While dot coms may outnumber traditional companies in our Top 200 Online Advertiser rankings, the story is not quite the same when the trend is examined across industries. Heavy spending Web Media companies dominate advertiser rankings, and a look into that industry reveals that 85 percent of the advertisers in Web Media are dot coms.

Also highly dominated by dot com companies are both the Retail and Business-to Business industries with 74 and 61 percent of the Top 200 Online Advertisers coming from dot coms.

While dot coms are leading the biggest industries, traditional companies heavily populate many industries. The Hardware & Electronics and Consumer Goods industries are populated primarily by traditional companies who represent 97 percent of their advertisers.

 
 
 
Percent of Dot Com Companies
Top 200 Advertisers by Industry
 

Comparing the number of advertisers by industry to the actual share of impressions by industry results in interesting findings illustrating how dot com advertisers often account for a larger share of impressions than traditional companies:

If every company in the Top 200 Online Advertiser rankings committed the same amount of impressions, one could anticipate that the percent of companies represented by dot coms would equal the percent of impressions by dot coms. Therefore the percent of companies could be used to determine expected ad spending by dot coms. Comparing actual spend to expected spend helps to shed light on which industries are being dominated by dot com ad spending.

Interestingly, while dot coms might not account for the majority of companies in the top rankings by industry, in some instances the few companies that are in the Top 200 dominate ad spending.

While only 32 of the Top 200 software advertisers are dot coms, they account for 86 percent of all impressions of the Top 200 software advertisers. The same story applies for the travel industry where 48 of the Top 200 travel companies account for 80 percent of all Top 200 travel advertising impressions.

 
 
 
Dot Com Deviation from Expected Spend
Top 200 Advertisers by Industry
 
Percent of Impressions Placed by Dot Coms
Top 200 Advertisers by Industry
 
 

In some industries, a single company dominates the ad spending for the entire industry. This is the case with the travel industry where Lowestfare.com accounts for 37 percent of all advertising impressions.

 
 
 
Company Share of Impressions
Lowestfare.com 37%
TRIP.com 10%
Europcar 9%
Expedia 6%
Hotel Reservation Network 4%
Travelscape.com 3%
Travelocity 3%
leisureplanet.com 3%
Delta Air Lines 3%
Yahoo! Travel 2%
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

While advertising on the Internet continues to grow, dot com advertisers continue to be big spenders accounting for a significant portion of online advertising impressions. When compared to traditional advertisers, the average dot com appears to be spending more aggressively, typically outspending traditional advertisers.

Despite the dominance of dot coms, traditional advertisers have managed to stake a claim in some industries. No doubt as traditional advertisers become more comfortable with online advertising they will begin to spend more of their budgets on the Internet, but until that day comes, the dot coms are in the driver's seat.

 
 
 

1 Dot com: Any company that originated on the Internet or whose existence is dependent on the existence of the Internet.

 
 


The AdRelevance Service provides advertisers, agencies and publishers with marketing intelligence that tells them when, where and how the competition is communicating on the web. If you are looking for a service that enables you to better plan, place, develop and execute your online communications programs, call AdRelevance toll-free at 1.877.884.5083.
 


Client Sign InIntelligence CenterServicesAbout UsHomeHomeIntelligence CenterIntelligence ReportPublished DataSnapshotReport ArchiveHome